Open Letter to Schools, Parents, Coaches and Young Sportsmen and Women

by Greg Wilmot | Narrated by Chirag Patel

In South Africa, I believe that one sporting event we do better than any other nation are school Derby Day clashes. From U9s to 1st teams and all the way down to E, F and G teams, ancient and bitter rivals vie to claim honour in the pool, on the court, the astro or the 1st team pitch. Throngs of learners, parents, and old boys and girls flock to these mega-events on Saturdays while school cheerleaders have spent the week practicing and choreographing war cries and school blazer animations. Personally, I recall sleepless Friday nights tossing and turning thinking about tomorrow’s cricket match, playing through shot selection and fantasising about successes.

At a glance, this makes for a heady-mix of blood, sweat, adrenalin and high hopes for young up-and-coming sportsmen and women who dream one day of making it big! However, scratch the surface a little and it soon becomes apparent that the current climate of school sport could be having a detrimental effect on children staying physically active throughout adulthood.

The statistics on obesity and sedentary lifestyles in South Africa make for scary reading;

  • Nearly 50% of men and 60% of women aged 25 to 34 live physically inactive lives.
  • Three million South Africans currently suffer from diabetes, the majority of which is Type-2 diabetes.
  • More than five million people in South Africa are pre-diabetic.
  • Of the BRICS nations, the women and men of South Africa suffer the highest and second highest rates of heart disease respectively.
  • 29% of men and 56% of women are obese.

Firstly, I am well aware that correlation between variables does not automatically imply causation. However, it is surely a contradiction that on the one hand, we are sports mad but on the other, the majority of our sports participation is from the comfort of the couch. What are we doing wrong? Why don’t our children stay physically active for life? Is there something wrong with the setting of sport and school derbies?

Recently, the Sports Minister, Fikile Mbablula, lambasted Bafana Bafana for a more than lack lustre performance at the African Nations Championship that resulted in their premature exit. He described the team as “a bunch of losers”, singling out the goalkeeper, Moeneeb Josephs, after he conceded a penalty and subsequently a goal. Indeed, we usually expect great things from ‘professional’ athletes but we also, wrongly, expect ‘professional’ performances from “talented” school-level athletes. This projection of expectations onto young athletes is fraught with danger and happens all too often in South African school sport. We expect greatness from those carrying our own hopes, dreams and ambitions but don’t consider the potential impact of our expectations.

A host of recent Sport Psychology research tells us that the “motivational climate” we construct as parents, coaches and schools has a large role to play in determining our attitudes towards sport and exercise. Sport is a common language that transcends boundaries, barriers and backgrounds but how we as South Africans talk about sport and sporting success or failure will contribute greatly to  both adult’s and children’s attitudes and beliefs about sport.

We’ve all seen or at least heard chirps about refereeing decisions, moans about team selections or enthusiastic cheers and coaching. Usually, these quips and comments are usually quite funny to recollect but many more have a highly disconcerting dark side.

Several years ago, I had a close encounter with an emotionally over-invested hockey coach in a warm-up match between two U16 girls teams. Midway through the first half, one of the opposing team players made an attempt to stop a ball on her ‘weak’ left side instead of the ‘strong’ right side which she would have easily achieved with some deft foot work. Having now conceded possession, the visibly frustrated coach aggressively questioned the already dejected player from a few metres away; “Do you know why that happened? Do you know why? Because you were weak!” Of course, the coach’s implication was a fault of technique but the reality of the statement “Because you were weak” left me chilled to the depths of my soul! I shudder to think about that poor girl’s relationship with sport and whether she has a shred of sporting confidence left.

The messages we broadcast to young sportsmen and women from the sidelines will have no less of an impact than the messages they encounter from parents, teachers and peers in the home or school environment. A young athlete might be told they were “weak” leading to them withdrawing from a context where they have received messages of being incapable, un-athletic or unskilled. Surely, by now we know that it is poor practice for parents or teachers to amplify mistakes, faults and weaknesses in the home or classroom? Why then do we assume that it is permissible to call any athlete, professional or not, a “bunch of losers”? Unfortunately, there is the belief that communication and interaction within sport is fundamentally different and it is just part of the game.

As Newton’s Third Law states; “For every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction.” Simple enough to witness on the hockey or rugby field on a Saturday, we don’t always consider the equal and opposite emotional reaction of children and adolescents to excessive pressure or poorly chosen words from parents, coaches, peers or the school at large. While young sportsmen and women often seem resilient in a culture where “cowboys don’t cry”, young athletes will react directly and indirectly in the sporting arena according to the demands placed on them.

Recent research done at schools in Kwa-Zulu Natal found that two-thirds of schoolboys believed it was acceptable to take steroids and that such performance enhancement didn’t constitute cheating. Quite simply, my view is that the taking of supplements and steroids is a literal ‘arms race’ to get bigger and stronger faster than their rival to be competitive on a stage where the pressure to win extends beyond their psychological skills to cope with the demands. What alternative choice do they believe they have?

In the last decade in South African school sport, there has been an explosion of media coverage, particularly of rugby, cricket, netball and hockey. The FNB Classic Clashes series has become a firm fixture on the TV schedule where the oldest and biggest rivals ‘duke’ it out in front of capacity crowds and a host of television viewers. By 2010, 46 Classic Clashes were featured on television with up to two games featured every week during the winter season. The Craven Week and the Coca-Cola / Khaya Majola Cricket weeks are always the highlights in the school sporting TV coverage as the cream of the crop vie for selection into the SA Schools or U19 teams. Furthermore, online media, magazines and newspapers frequently report sports results and profile rising stars with a few assorted articles and a well known sponsor.

That ‘amateur’ and ‘adolescent’ sport so closely imitates professional and adult sport in so many ways is a cause for concern. I often describe the professionalisation of school sport to friends and colleagues as a “runaway freight train” which we can’t stop. The facts that Derby Days are getting bigger, sponsorships are increasing and that school sport is broadcast across various media are all factors we cannot easily rein-in. However, what parents, coaches and schools can do in mitigation is to look extremely closely at the environments they construct and the performance demands they place on their charges.

There needs to be a crucial shift in developing schoolboys and girls that can cope with the demands they encounter at the sharp end of a Derby Day match but also ensure derbies are not experienced as life and death events! School derbies are the lifeblood of our successful national teams but they are also, too often, the events that severe potentially lifelong relationships with sport and a healthy nation in the future.

A valuable departure point for these groups is to review and realign the personal, institutional and social importance they attach to the successes of their team, school or child. The value and personal esteem we attach to the highs and lows of our favourite professional sporting heroes and teams cannot and must not take place in school-level sport. If child and adolescent development is already fraught with so many existing challenges, particularly academic success, why then is it acceptable to project personal hopes, wishes and fantasies of athletic success onto young sportsmen and women?

My appeal is this; the relationship adults have with sport and physical activity is based on the accumulation of emotions, attitudes and beliefs that are developed during their schooling career and earlier. If winning is everything to a coach and mistakes are lambasted with belittling comments, children will do the same to themselves and their peers who fail. The gap between the potential of an athlete and the expectation of a coach, parent or school ethos can quickly become a chasm of disappointment, anger and withdrawal for young sportsmen and women. Spectators, parents, coaches and schools need to carefully evaluate EVERY message they communicate, whether subtle or overt, to young sportsmen and women. Coaches at every level of school sport need to become experts in communication and self-reflection; carefully calculating and reviewing the CONTENT of their words, HOW they speak but also what they DO!

We are currently heading down a rabbit hole of school sport development and professionalization. The only questions being; How far does it go and what lies at the other end? My hope is that we can develop a clear capacity for self-reflection and insight of our own actions in the hope of developing kids and adults that remain active for life! I hope 2014 is a happy and successful sporting year!

Greg Wilmot, Counselling & Sport Psychologist, Grahamstown.

greg@wilmotpsychology.co.za