Winter Reflection
With winter sports now truly a thing of the past, spring hails the start of the traditional athletics season. Each season we are quick to make the transition from one sport to the next. Sometimes sportsmen and women are disappointed but other times relieved. Moving onto a new seasons provides fresh opportunity to excel in a sport or discipline that matches their skills and ability. With such hast, are there not important lessons and events to reflect on that could bring fresh hope, relief or perspective to the new season?
In my opinion, one of the most significant events from the winter sport season took place in late August. Following resounding defeats for all but two rugby teams in their annual fixture against traditional rivals Glenwood, Hilton College released a statement reporting that they would no longer compete against Glenwood in forthcoming seasons. There now existed a performance “mismatch” between the schools. The annual day of rugby matches had become “one-sided” leading to an “increased risk or injury” and leaving “no educational value” for the schoolboy sportsmen involved on either side.
It was only ever going to be at the time of such a watershed decision, as made by Hilton College that we would realised how real the professionalization of school sport in South Africa is. The assessment by Hilton College that Glenwood has “moved into a different league” is, in all likelihood, an accurate one. Simply, schoolboy (and sometimes schoolgirl) sport has become a numbers game. Unfortunately, regardless of how much pride, tradition and guts a team displays, they will for simple statistical reasons usually lose to a bigger school. Typically, the best athletes are a small group of highly specialised performers with unique skills and physiology that make up a tiny proportion of a population. Bigger schools, (which are typically “Government” or “Former Model C”) have more pupils and consequently have more “genetically talented” players available. In contrast, many independent (or Private) schools have smaller population sizes and, typically, are coeducational which then halves their available rugby playing population.
While smaller school numbers is a sound argument, it doesn’t take into account that some people simply choose not to play the sport or are genetically incapable. The latter justification has nothing to do with being unskilled or because they are “chicken” but simply because of the genes they received from their parents. When it comes to playing rugby physical size and bulk will more often than not beat skill and / or speed. To be competitive at the top-end of schoolboy or professional rugby, you need to be genetically “gifted” with bulk. Consider that bigger schools will likely have a greater proportion of bigger available rugby players and the “mismatch” between traditional rivals is inevitable.
The fact that we are entering an era of “professionalised” and genetically selective sport at school level is highly disconcerting. That you didn’t make the team is moving away from beliefs around courage, effort or motivation and could soon employ justifications of “I genetically can’t”.
However, one possible lesson for schools, coaches and parents in the current age of “either you’ve got it or you don’t” is the need for diversity and availability of alternative sporting options. Potentially talented middle distance runners, mountain bikers or golfers are unlikely to enjoy having their available sporting options limited, for example, by having to lay rugby. Instead, they will benefit from lessons learned that they have infinite potential that needs to be discovered.
Greg Wilmot is a Counselling and Sport Psychologist based at Health & Sport Inc., in Grahamstown. You can contact him on 072 264 1452 or email wilmot.greg@gmail.com. Website: gregwilmotsportpsych.yolasite.com Twitter: @gregsportpsych